Posted: 7:00 a.m. Sunday, Feb. 15, 2015

FOCUS ON TAXES

Half of Butler County school districts see drop in property values

By Rick McCrabb

Staff Writer

BUTLER COUNTY — 

    Half of the Butler County public school districts saw a drop in their appraised property values last year, and now the districts will have to deal with a substantial loss of tax revenue.

    The value of the property last year, compared to 2013, dropped $66.3 million, or .89 percent, said Julie Joyce-Smith, real estate manager for the Butler County Auditor’s Office. Five districts experienced these losses even though the value of the county’s agricultural land rose nearly $48 million, or 27 percent.

    Joyce-Smith said she’s “cautiously optimistic” that the property values in the county will increase next year because she’s seeing a rise in county building permits and hopes that’s a sign construction is bouncing back.

    School districts receive tax revenue from agricultural, residential, industrial and commercial properties and public utilities. Values from 2014 will be billed this year, the auditor’s office said.

    Of the 10 public schools districts in the county, Hamilton and Middletown experienced the largest drop in property values, particularly in residential.

    In Hamilton, the district’s property values last year dropped $51.9 million, or 6.4 percent, from 2013. Hamilton’s residential values dropped $48 million from 2013 to last year.

    Bob Hancock, the district’s treasurer, said the financial impact on the general fund is “insignificant” because the effective tax rate will be increased to counter the decrease in taxable value and the district will collect approximately the same amount of taxes.

    He said the permanent improvement fund, which has 3.5 mills that flow into it, will experience a reduction as a result of the valuation decrease. The annual loss in revenue for the permanent improvement funds will be $181,000. The annual revenue into the permanent improvement funds from local taxes is approximately $2.6 million.

    He said the loss of $181,000 won’t have “an immediate impact” on the district.

Decreases in valuation can also make the district look poorer in the state funding calculation and that generally leads to additional state funding, Hancock said.         Determining exactly what that translates into in terms of state funding is dependent upon how assessed valuation is used in the calculation going forward and Hamilton is likely to be receiving a capped amount, he said.

    Meanwhile in Middletown, values dropped $52 million, or 7.39 percent, from 2013 to last year. The values in residential properties in Middletown fell $50 million from 2013 to 2014.

    The two largest gains were seen in heavily agricultural districts, Talawanda and Ross. Talawanda property values rose $20 million, or 3 percent, while Ross jumped $9 million, or 2.4 percent, according to the county.

    The drop in property values is a trend in Middletown. District Treasurer Randy Bertram said for the sixth consecutive year, and eight out of the last nine years, property values in the district fell.

    He said that means the district will receive $1.3 million less in property tax revenue over the next two years — $500,000 less during the current fiscal year that ends June 30, 2015 and an estimated $800,000 less in property tax revenue the following fiscal year, he said.

    “Money is tight,” he said, “and we are watching it closely.”

To help offset the loss of tax revenue, Bertram said the district isn’t replacing staff with full-time employees, but long-term substitutes for the remainder of the school year. The district also is assessing its staffing to determine the needs for next year.

    He said the district also is reviewing current purchased services and deciding if the service is needed, can be reduced, and looking for alternatives to reduce the contract costs.

    Now, Bertram said, the district’s five-year forecast will be updated, and the district will take any “necessary actions” for this and the next fiscal year. He said the district may have to make adjustments to assure it ends the fiscal year in the black.

    Just 10 years ago, Bertram said, the property values in the city exceeded $1 billion.     Since then, there have been five significant drops: 6.62 percent in 2007; 11.94 percent in 2009; 8.22 percent in 2010; 7.89 percent in 2011 and 7.39 percent last year, he said.

Overall, since 2005, the district has seen a drop of 39.4 percent in property taxes, Bertram said.

    “I can only hope that we are at the bottom,” he said.

    Bertram said Middletown is $15 million under funded by the state, according to the formula. He said the state is considering raising the cap districts can receive. He said if the state raises the cap by 5 percent, the Middletown district would receive $1.7 million more for fiscal year 2016.

    “We certainly are hopeful,” Bertram said about the state possibly increasing school funding.

    Even if that occurs, Bertram said, the Middletown district would be under funded in 2019.

    Madison saw a drop off about $483,120 in its property taxes, which will cost the district about $12,000 to its general funds. Treasurer Rich Natiello said that was not “a material amount” of money.

    He said Madison, and all districts throughout the state, are eagerly anticipating the state budget, expected to be released in June.

    In the six categories, agricultural saw the largest increase in property value. The value of farm land in the county went from $175.8 million in 2013 to $223.8 million last year.      Only the Fairfield district saw a drop in the value of its agricultural land.

    Property taxes on farmland are skyrocketing because a combination of economic and crop-price conditions have affected state calculations designed to keep working farms from being taxed as possible subdivisions, according to the Ohio Department of Taxes.     The so-called Current Agricultural Use Value (CAUV) formula, which was adopted in the mid-’70s, has historically kept appraised values on cropland at a small fraction of its market value.

    Active cropland in the county was appraised at an average of about a quarter of its market value from 1996 through 2013, data from the Ohio Department of Taxation shows.

    Now the CAUV will set the farmland value at two-thirds of market value.

    Ten years ago, the average property value of an acre of farmland was $123, said     Shelley Wilson from the Ohio Department of Taxes. Now, she said, it’s $1,668. She said the value of farmland is getting “caught up” after years of being undervalued.

    The sharp rise, according to experts, is a result of high crop prices during recent years and continued historically low interest rates. Both result in higher CAUV values, and thus higher property tax bills, officials said.

    As for residential values, local Realtors had a difficult time explaining the sharp drop in values.

    Michael Combs, manager of Coldwell Bank Oyer Inc., said he was surprised by the drop of property values in the county, particularly in Middletown. He said prices of homes have “gone up a couple of ticks.” He said business is strong and Realtors and homeowners are “happy and proud” of real estate sales, and that wasn’t the case two or three years ago.

    Paul Renwick, president of the recently formed board of Realtors from Butler and Warren counties, said there is “good stock” of homes in the area. He said property values have “dipped a little” and he doesn’t know why that happened.

 

LOOKIE! LOOKIE!

How special....we are number #1 again

Town's not worth much. Property's not worth much. Schools aren't worth much. No desire from outsiders to value Middletown and what it has to offer. City has been run into the ground, been in freefall and has the reputation of a leper colony as to attraction. Schools revenue among many things that have suffered. Result.......this outcome.

The news is consistent around here and usually in a negative light......the city is usually last whenever comparisons are made, regardless of topic.

Bertrum says he can "only hope we are at the bottom". I wouldn't bet on it.

Thanks city leaders for making the city the least desired of any around here.

It is astonishing that none of them realize they're going the wrong direction and need to change, especially when they see data like this.

Apparently, ignorance has no boundaries.